Belmond Hotel Caruso vs Le Sirenuse: Which Amalfi Coast Hotel to Book
Editor's Top Pick
Check rates at Belmond Hotel Caruso
Our editor's top pick for this guide.
The hotel's official site
The stays we’d book
Editor’s shortlist
Caruso, A Belmond Hotel, Amalfi Coast
Ravello, Amalfi Coast, Italy · Check dates for rates
Best for: Ravello, above the coast — the view everyone books for
Le Sirenuse
Positano, Amalfi Coast, Italy · Check dates for rates
Best for: Positano itself — walkable dinners, the cascade view
Rates and availability are shown on the booking partner’s site, or the property’s own where we have no partner.
The short version
Caruso is a hilltop retreat with an unmatched view; Le Sirenuse is a town hotel in the most photographed village in Italy. If you want to arrive, unpack and not move, Caruso. If you want to step out of the door into Positano at seven in the evening, Le Sirenuse. Both are genuinely five-star with long-tenured staff; neither will disappoint on service.
Setting and the view
Caruso occupies an 11th-century palazzo in Ravello, high above Amalfi town. The infinity pool appears to end in the Gulf of Salerno, and the gardens are the property's second act — pergolas, lemon trees, morning light that photographs like a painting. Le Sirenuse looks across Positano's cascade of pastel houses to the Church of Santa Maria Assunta's majolica dome. It is a busier, warmer, more human view; Caruso's is cinematic.
Rooms
Caruso's rooms are larger on average, with vaulted ceilings, frescoes in the historic categories and terraces on the sea-facing rooms. Book a Deluxe Sea View or above; garden-view rooms are lovely but miss the reason you came. Le Sirenuse's rooms vary considerably — the property grew room by room over seventy years — so the category matters more than at any other hotel on the coast. Superior Sea View is the entry point worth booking; below that, expect a partial view.
Dining and the evening
Caruso's restaurant — now Ristorante Il Pantaleone by Armando Aristarco, formerly Belvedere — is a special-occasion room with one of Italy's great terraces, and the Pool Restaurant handles lunch. Ravello has perhaps six restaurants of note in total, so most dinners happen in-house — pleasant if that is what you want, limiting if not. Le Sirenuse has La Sponda, lit by 400 candles, plus Franco's Bar next door, still the best aperitivo on the coast. Positano's dinner options run into the dozens and are walkable.
Beach access and getting around
Neither has a private beach club in the manner of Il San Pietro. Caruso runs a shuttle down to a beach club in Amalfi — around 25 minutes each way on the coast road. Le Sirenuse is a five-minute walk from Spiaggia Grande and a short walk to quieter Fornillo, with the hotel's own boats leaving from the beach. For a family, or anyone who wants a swim without a car journey, Positano is the easier base.
Rates and booking windows
Peak-season (June to early September) rates run roughly from €1,300 a night at Caruso and €1,600 at Le Sirenuse for the sea-view categories, with suites well beyond that. Both close for winter and reopen in April. May, late September and October are materially cheaper and, for our money, better trips. Both hotels sell out 6–9 months ahead for July and August; Caruso's pool-view categories go first.
Why this is right for you
Choose Caruso for a honeymoon, an anniversary or a second Amalfi trip, when the pleasure is in staying put — long breakfasts on the terrace, an afternoon in the garden, dinner without leaving the property. Choose Le Sirenuse when you want the holiday to have a village in it: a walk to the beach in the morning, a boat to Capri after lunch, and a table somewhere different every night. Readers who split the difference book three nights in Positano followed by two in Ravello, and almost never regret that order.
Source note — checked 10 October 2026
On 10 October 2026 we updated only the name of Caruso's restaurant — now Ristorante Il Pantaleone by Armando Aristarco, formerly Belvedere — from Belmond's official sources. Other details in this comparison were not re-checked on that date.
Related Guides
Where to Stay
Where to Stay
Properties referenced in this article, chosen by our editorial team.
